Do overweight dogs live shorter lives?

On this page

1. The 50,787-dog study (Salt et al., 2019)
2. The Labrador diet study (Kealy et al., 2002)
3. Arthritis: 2.3 times (Banfield)
4. Why: joints, inflammation, breathing, heat
5. What reverses it
6. The point of tracking

Yes, by a lot. The largest study, of 50,787 neutered dogs across twelve breeds, found overweight dogs had shorter median lifespans in every breed: five months less for German Shepherds, roughly a year for Labradors, up to two and a half years less for Yorkshire Terriers. In the fourteen-year Labrador study, dogs kept lean lived a median 1.8 years longer than their overfed siblings and got arthritis years later. And overweight dogs are about 2.3 times as likely to be diagnosed with osteoarthritis. Fat is not padding; it is an organ that shortens lives.

The 50,787-dog study (Salt et al., 2019)

Researchers from the University of Liverpool and the WALTHAM Petcare Science Institute took the records of 50,787 neutered dogs seen at Banfield hospitals across the US, in twelve popular breeds, and compared lifespan between dogs recorded as overweight and dogs at a normal body condition. The paper, in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine, found overweight dogs lived shorter lives in every breed. The gap ranged from about five months in German Shepherds to two and a half years in Yorkshire Terriers, with Labradors, Goldens, Beagles, Dachshunds, Shih Tzus and others in between. The pattern that small breeds paid the most is consistent with what fat does to a small body: the same excess is a larger fraction of it.

It is an observational study, so it shows association rather than proof of cause. That is what the next study is for.

The Labrador diet study (Kealy et al., 2002)

This is the experiment. Forty-eight Labrador Retrievers from seven litters were paired by sex and weight at eight weeks old. One of each pair ate what it wanted within reason; the other was fed 25 percent less than its sibling, for life. Nothing else differed. Published in the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association after fourteen years, the results were stark: the lean-fed dogs lived a median 13.0 years against 11.2, an extra 1.8 years, and the onset of chronic disease, above all osteoarthritis, came about two years later. By age ten, half the free-fed dogs had died; among the lean-fed dogs it took until about age thirteen. Purina, which ran the study, summarises it as "a lean body condition can extend a dog's life by nearly two years".

Arthritis: 2.3 times (Banfield)

Banfield's State of Pet Health report draws on records from millions of veterinary visits a year. Its finding on joints is simple: overweight dogs are about 2.3 times as likely to be diagnosed with osteoarthritis as dogs at a healthy weight, and overweight and arthritis run together in the same dogs. It is a loop: excess weight loads the joints, inflamed joints hurt, hurting dogs move less, dogs that move less get heavier. Breaking it usually takes weight loss and pain management at the same time, and the senior version of that problem is in How much exercise does a senior dog need?.

Why: joints, inflammation, breathing, heat

• Mechanical load. Every extra pound is carried on four joints, thousands of times a day. Cartilage wears; cruciate ligaments tear more often in heavy dogs.
• Inflammation. Fat tissue is metabolically active; it secretes inflammatory signals that are linked to arthritis, insulin resistance and some cancers, which is why "just a bit chubby" is not neutral.
• Breathing and heat. Fat around the chest and neck makes breathing harder work, especially in flat-faced breeds, and insulation makes overheating easier; see How hot is too hot to walk a dog?.
• Diabetes and other disease. Overweight dogs are at higher risk of diabetes, pancreatitis and urinary problems, and surgery and anaesthesia carry more risk.

What reverses it

The studies measure lifelong condition, not the effect of losing weight late, but every mechanism above improves when the weight comes off, and vets routinely see arthritic dogs move visibly better after losing a body condition point. The recipe is unglamorous: a target weight (estimate it with the method in How much should my dog weigh?), a ration computed for that target rather than the current weight (the calorie needs calculator shows the formula vets use), treats inside the ration, and daily walking to keep muscle on and joints moving while the fat goes. The eight-week version is Helping your dog lose weight by walking: an 8-week plan.

The point of tracking

Fifty-nine percent of US dogs are overweight, according to the last veterinary-assessed APOP survey, and only about a third of owners think theirs is. The two-and-a-half years in the Salt study were lost a pound at a time by people who loved their dogs and did not notice. Noticing is the whole game: a monthly weigh-in against a known ideal, the ribs-waist-tuck check in Is my dog overweight? How to check in two minutes, and a walking record honest enough to show when the miles quietly dropped. None of that is diet advice. It is the part of the evidence you can act on before the vet visit, instead of after.

Frequently asked questions

How much does obesity shorten a dog's life?

In the largest study, by breed: five months for German Shepherds, about a year for Labradors and Golden Retrievers, and up to two and a half years for Yorkshire Terriers, comparing overweight dogs with those at a healthy body condition. Small breeds lost the most.

Is the Labrador study reliable?

It is one of the best-designed studies in veterinary nutrition: 48 Labradors from seven litters, paired, one of each pair fed 25 percent less than its sibling from puppyhood, followed for life. Lean dogs lived a median 1.8 years longer and developed chronic conditions about two years later.

Do overweight dogs get arthritis?

They get it more and earlier. Banfield's State of Pet Health report, from millions of veterinary visits, found overweight dogs about 2.3 times as likely to be diagnosed with osteoarthritis, and the two conditions reinforce each other.

Can losing weight add years back?

The studies measure lifelong condition rather than reversal, but the mechanisms (joint load, inflammation, insulin resistance, breathing) all improve when weight comes off, and vets see arthritic dogs move better within weeks of losing a few pounds. Earlier is better; later still helps.

This guide is general information from published veterinary and scientific sources, not veterinary advice. Every dog is different: for exercise, weight or feeding decisions, talk to your vet. Pawdometer never gives diet advice.